FERC’s PJM ruling and Virginia’s merger fight both ask: who pays for data centers?

Two regulatory proceedings in the PJM Interconnection’s footprint converged this month on the same unresolved question: who bears the cost of connecting data centers to the grid, and who gets to decide. On October 9, 2026, the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission largely rejected PJM’s plan for bringing large loads onto its system. Three days earlier, in Fairfax County, Virginia, state and local officials used a public hearing on the proposed $67 billion Dominion Energy-NextEra Energy merger to press the same point from the state level.

Neither case is resolved. Together they show a grid operator, a federal regulator and a state commission all wrestling with the same arithmetic: data center demand is arriving faster than new generation can be built, and someone has to absorb the gap in the meantime.

What FERC rejected

PJM, which serves 13 states and the District of Columbia, had proposed an Interim Resource Adequacy Service, or IRAS, that would let new large loads such as data centers connect to the grid without matching new generation, provided they agreed to be curtailed ahead of grid emergencies. It paired that with a “bring your own new capacity,” or BYONC, option for loads willing to add generation themselves.

Key elements of PJM’s Interim Resource Adequacy Service framework, which would allow large loads to connect to the grid without matching new generation if they agree to be curtailed in the lead-up to grid emergencies, intrude on state jurisdiction over retail rates and appear to discriminate against large loads, FERC said. A separate legal analysis of the order found that several provisions of the proposed tariff appear to place obligations directly on retail customers, dictate which retail customers would be curtailed, and establish what amounts to a retail rate, a matter for states to regulate.

FERC did not reject everything. It accepted PJM’s definition of a large load as 50 MW or more at a single site, and a large-load registry, both effective October 12, 2026. The commission also flagged a reliability conflict in the curtailment design: it noted that the relevant reliability standard permits firm loads to be curtailed only after a more severe grid emergency alert than PJM’s proposal contemplated, which would have curtailed some firm load earlier.

PJM’s own response was measured. Spokesman Jeffrey Shields said the grid operator is reviewing the order with “an eye toward how we can fulfill FERC’s requirements while recognizing the responsibilities FERC indicated belong to the states and honoring the concept that existing electricity customers should not be unfairly burdened by new, energy intensive customers in the form of higher costs or decreased reliability.”

Four auctions, a tenfold price jump

The reason this ruling matters commercially is visible in PJM’s capacity auction results. The auction sets what load-serving entities pay generators to be available three years ahead, and that cost flows through to retail bills as a capacity charge.

Capacity prices have soared from $28.92 per megawatt-day in 2024/25 to $329.17 per megawatt-day in 2026/27. The 2026/27 price would have been even higher if PJM had not imposed a price cap for the auction. The following auction, for 2027/28, hit a $333.44/MW-day price cap across the region, a record for the third auction in a row. The most recent auction, for 2028/29, cleared lower at $325/MW-day but still came up short: it cleared with a 6.8 GW supply shortfall and a $325 price cap, signaling a structural inability to meet projected demand, according to one industry analysis.

PJM capacity auction clearing price by delivery year
PJM capacity auction clearing price by delivery year

The Mid-Atlantic zones where data centers are most concentrated cleared well above the RTO-wide average. The BGE and Dominion zones cleared at $466.35 and $444.26 per MW-day respectively for 2026/27, reflecting tighter supply conditions in the Mid-Atlantic region where data center concentration is highest. That is the zone covering much of Dominion Energy’s Virginia service territory, the same territory at the center of the merger hearing.

PJM 2026/27 capacity price by zone
PJM 2026/27 capacity price by zone

Equity analysts read the FERC order as good news for power plant owners. The ruling will potentially lead to higher capacity prices for longer in PJM, which is favorable to independent power producers such as Constellation Energy, NRG Energy, Talen Energy and Vistra, Jefferies analysts wrote in a client note, saying “the latest development is positive for existing generation/IPPs.” Higher-for-longer capacity prices are the flip side of FERC blocking a mechanism that would have let new data centers connect faster without paying for new generation up front.

Virginia’s parallel fight over the same question

While FERC was writing its order, Virginia’s State Corporation Commission was holding local hearings on whether to approve NextEra’s proposed acquisition of Dominion Energy, a deal that would create what the companies describe as the largest regulated electric utility in the country. At an October 9 hearing in Fairfax County, the debate was almost entirely about data centers and rates.

Virginia Delegate Irene Shin recounted a moment from an earlier legislative hearing that she said troubled her: “When Dominion was asked about the Virginia Clean Economy Act, its executive vice president told the commission, ‘I am still your throat to choke,’ and that was a shocking thing for me to hear as a legislator,” she said.

Alexandria City Councilman John Taylor Chapman told the commission “our concern is that the creation of the nation’s largest electric utility will put Alexandrians at risk of runaway utility costs.” Most officials who spoke that night asked for the merger to be denied or allowed only contingent on guarantees like Virginia Clean Economy Act compliance, data centers paying for infrastructure costs, and prohibitions on regulated utilities making campaign contributions. Business and union leaders took the opposite position, speaking in favor of the deal and citing job creation and the need to meet electricity demand. At a separate hearing the same week, speakers were overwhelmingly worried the costs of powering a growing number of data centers in the area will get passed off to them.

Dominion’s exposure to data center load is large and growing. “Data centers currently represent about 20 percent of our total sales in Virginia and have provided strong sales growth to date,” chief executive Bob Blue said on an earnings call, pointing to Amazon Web Services’ expansion plans as evidence the industry is still growing. One industry tracker puts the figure higher, estimating that data centers now consume over 25% of Virginia’s total electricity.

Table: who is arguing what

Party Position on data center costs
FERC Rejected PJM’s curtailment and BYONC framework as reaching into state retail-rate authority and potentially discriminatory; kept a 50 MW large-load registry.
PJM Interconnection Says it is redesigning its filing to meet FERC’s requirements while protecting existing customers from new large-load costs, per spokesman Jeffrey Shields.
Jefferies equity analysts View the FERC order as favorable to independent power producers because it extends a higher-for-longer capacity price environment.
Virginia state and local officials Largely asked the SCC to deny or condition approval of the Dominion-NextEra merger on data centers paying infrastructure costs.
NextEra chief executive John Ketchum Says the combined company is “fully committed to ensuring that data centers pay their fair share.”
Local business and union representatives Backed the merger, citing job creation and the need to meet rising electricity demand.

Who gains, who loses

The clearest winners from the FERC order are owners of existing generation in PJM. A market that stays tight for longer, because new large loads cannot bypass the capacity queue as easily, supports the prices that plants like Constellation’s nuclear fleet and gas-fired units owned by NRG, Talen and Vistra can earn. That is the reading Jefferies gave its clients.

The clearer losers, in the near term, are data center developers who had hoped IRAS and BYONC would let them connect faster without first securing new generation. FERC’s registry requirement at least gives PJM visibility into where those loads are concentrated, but the curtailment and cost-allocation questions now revert to individual states, a slower and more fragmented process than a single RTO-wide tariff.

For residential ratepayers in the Dominion and BGE zones, the picture is mixed. A tighter capacity market for longer keeps upward pressure on the capacity-charge portion of bills. At the same time, pushing cost-allocation decisions to the state level is exactly what Virginia officials asked for at the merger hearing: a louder voice in deciding whether data centers or households absorb new infrastructure costs.

Dominion and NextEra have already moved to blunt the backlash. The companies said they now want to offer an average residential customer a $10 monthly bill credit for four years instead of the two years originally proposed. NextEra would boost the funds available for Virginia bill credits from $1.78 billion to $1.87 billion, according to Ketchum, partly by shifting credits away from data centers and toward residential customers. Ketchum also said he agreed with Virginia Governor Abigail Spanberger’s position that data centers should pay the full cost of service, including her argument that the commission should shift more of the cost of high-voltage transmission lines to data centers.

Not every official is satisfied. Richmond Mayor Danny Avula called the revised package “encouraging” but said “ratepayers, especially vulnerable ratepayers, our local workforce and our capital city need to be represented in this process.” State Senator Louise Lucas put it more bluntly: “As always, I stand with the people of the Commonwealth and I want data centers to pay their fair share.”

Open questions

Several things remain unsettled. PJM has not yet filed a revised large-load proposal, so there is no confirmed timeline for when a workable interconnection pathway for new data centers will exist; in the meantime, the 50 MW registry gives the grid operator data but no enforcement tool. Analysts at mgrid, reviewing the order, argued that the decision effectively “moves the curtailment question to the states,” since FERC accepted a registry that gives PJM visibility into every 50 MW-plus load while rejecting a plan it found appears to dictate which retail customers are curtailed. Whether 13 different state commissions can coordinate fast enough to avoid further bottlenecks is untested.

On the merger side, the timeline is firmer but the outcome is not. The Virginia State Corporation Commission has scheduled an evidentiary hearing beginning November 17, 2026. NextEra and Dominion filed their Virginia merger application on July 15 and continue to target the second half of 2027 to close the transaction, subject to regulatory approvals. Under Virginia law the SCC has 180 days to decide, pushing the review into January 2027. The commission can approve the deal outright, reject it, or attach conditions on cost allocation, campaign contributions or clean-energy compliance, any of which could reshape how the combined company treats data center customers going forward.

The data shows capacity prices have risen roughly tenfold over four auction cycles and that Mid-Atlantic zones with the heaviest data center concentration are paying a premium over the RTO-wide price. A reasonable reading is that neither the FERC order nor a conditioned merger approval will by itself bring prices back down; both are procedural fixes to decide who negotiates the cost allocation, not reductions in the underlying demand growth driving it.

What to watch

  • PJM’s refiled large-load interconnection tariff, and whether it narrows curtailment obligations enough to satisfy FERC while still protecting existing customers, as PJM has said it intends to do.
  • The Virginia SCC’s November 17 evidentiary hearing on the Dominion-NextEra merger, and whether the commission attaches binding conditions on data center cost allocation before any approval.
  • PJM’s next base residual auction results, to see whether the FERC order’s emphasis on state-level curtailment control shows up as a further price signal or eases pressure as new generation and demand-response resources clear.
  • Whether other states in PJM’s footprint, beyond Virginia, move to adopt their own data center rate classes or cost-allocation rules now that FERC has pushed that authority back to them.

Sources