Europe’s wind build-out meets a grid bill that keeps rising

Europe’s wind fleet has outgrown the wires that carry its output, and the bill for the mismatch is now large enough to be changing policy. Recharge News framed the point this week with a headline saying Europe built the wind farms but neglected the grid. The numbers from Germany, Britain and the EU-wide studies support the direction of that argument, though they measure different things and should not be added together.

Two events this month show how the problem is being handled. On 7 October 2026 the German Bundestag’s economy and energy committee held a public hearing on the government’s bill to synchronise new generation with grid expansion and to improve the grid connection procedure. And in Britain, National Grid awarded Balfour Beatty a contract for the first phase of the Birkhill Wood 400 kV substation in East Yorkshire, the connection point for three planned offshore wind farms on the Dogger Bank.

What the data shows

Congestion costs are rising on both sides of the North Sea. The figures below come from different bodies, cover different years and use different definitions, so the table lists each with its source rather than offering a single European total.

Jurisdiction Measure Figure Period Reported by
Germany Redispatch costs (EUR bn) about 2.7 2025 Baker McKenzie summary of the draft grid package
Germany Congestion management (EUR bn per year) about 3 Annual, latest Economy ministry, via Clean Energy Wire
Europe Congestion management costs (EUR bn) nearly 9 2024 Aurora Energy Research, via Euronews
Seven European countries Renewable generation lost to grid limits (EUR bn) 7.2 2024 Beyond Fossil Fuels with E3G, Ember and IEEFA
Great Britain Thermal constraint costs (GBP bn) 1.82 2025 NESO data, via Delfos
Great Britain Thermal constraint costs (GBP bn) 1.383 1 January to 8 August 2026 NESO data, analysed by Tim Harper

In Germany, curtailment compensation plus balancing costs are ultimately borne by end consumers, with approximately EUR 2.7 billion in redispatch costs in 2025, according to Baker McKenzie’s reading of the draft. The economy ministry puts the annual figure at three billion euros.

At European level, a 2025 Aurora Energy Research study found that congestion management costs neared EUR 9 billion in 2024, while 72 TWh of mainly renewable energy was curtailed. The same study notes that grid investment in Europe rose 47 per cent over five years to around EUR 70 billion annually, which experts it cites consider insufficient.

Britain: a physical bottleneck with a rising price

In Great Britain, the issue is concentrated at the boundary between Scotland and England. When flows across that interface hit their safe limit, NESO pays Scottish wind farms to switch off and pays gas plants in England to switch on in their place. NESO data cited by Delfos shows the volume of constraint actions rose from 11 TWh in 2024 to 14.37 TWh in 2025, while thermal constraint costs rose from GBP 1.48 billion to GBP 1.82 billion.

Great Britain thermal constraint costs
Great Britain thermal constraint costs

The 2026 figures need careful reading. The Times reported that the narrower cost of turning down wind and replacing it has already passed GBP 1 billion, about GBP 300 million more than at the same point in 2025. An analysis of NESO’s broader thermal-constraint series by Tim Harper reaches GBP 1.383 billion by 8 August. He cautions that the headline is a combination of wind turn-down and the cost of replacing generation elsewhere, so it is not a payment total to wind farms alone.

Harper also points to causes beyond wind volumes. NESO says higher wind and reduced network capacity were the main reasons June constraint costs rose, and June wind curtailment was lower than a year earlier, but costs stayed high because replacement power was more expensive.

Forecasts diverge, and they are forecasts. One industry projection reported by Energy Live News says annual payments could rise to more than GBP 3 billion by 2027 if grid capacity lags generation. A separate analysis of NESO’s own projection puts costs at GBP 4 billion to GBP 8 billion a year by 2030 if network upgrades arrive late.

Germany moves the risk onto new projects

Berlin’s response is a regulatory one. The federal cabinet adopted the EEG reform and the grid connection package on 29 July, and Denkstrom reports that the final Bundestag vote is meant to come by the end of the year.

The draft’s central mechanism is the “Redispatch-Vorbehalt” (redispatch reservation). In hotspots where more than five percent of the previous year’s generation could not be fed into the grid, new renewable plants would get immediate connection only if they waive compensation for a share of future curtailments for up to six years. Uncompensated curtailment would be capped at 20 percent of annual yield, or 18 percent in wind priority areas. An earlier draft used a lower trigger: more than 3% of potential feed-in. The Stiftung Umweltenergierecht notes that capacity-limited areas are now meant to be designated only for ground-mounted PV and onshore wind.

The data on German curtailment adds context. A preprint analysing German support schemes finds that market-based curtailment in 2025 was 2.1 TWh for wind and 1.0 TWh for solar, while grid-related curtailment was larger, at about 6 TWh. The excerpt reviewed does not split the grid-related figure by technology. It is an author analysis, not an official statistic.

German curtailment in 2025
German curtailment in 2025

Dogger Bank shows the timing problem

The Birkhill Wood award illustrates how long grid assets take compared with turbines. The contract covers early contractor involvement, detailed design and enabling works, with main construction expected to start in 2027. National Grid received planning consent in June 2026, and the substation will connect 4.22 GW of offshore wind generation, according to National Grid.

Project Planned capacity (GW) Developers Status as reported
Dogger Bank South East 1.5 RWE, Masdar Consent May 2026; CfD in Allocation Round 7 (January 2026); FID targeted 2027; commissioning 2031
Dogger Bank South West 1.5 RWE, Masdar Consent May 2026; CfD in Allocation Round 7 (January 2026); FID targeted 2027; commissioning 2032
Dogger Bank D up to 1.5 SSE Renewables, Equinor Seabed lease held; still needs development consent and FID

The details come from Offshore Wind’s report on the award and its description of the SSE and Equinor project. The sequence matters: the onshore substation can start main works in 2027, the same year the two RWE and Masdar projects aim for a final investment decision. Delivery of the grid is a visible, scheduled step, which is the opposite of the Scottish situation, where upgrades trail the turbines already built.

Who gains and who loses

The data shows costs landing on three groups. Consumers pay through network charges; German law compensates curtailed plants for lost revenue and passes the cost, with the cost of turning up plants elsewhere, mostly into network charges. Developers in congested zones face lower revenue certainty if the German reservation passes as drafted. And owners of wind assets in high-wind markets face price effects: ENTSO-E’s 2026 market report, covering June 2025 to May 2026, finds that countries with a substantial share of wind generation show wind values 5 to 15 EUR/MWh below average day-ahead prices. It reports a spread across markets, with Italy at 114 EUR/MWh and Finland at 35 EUR/MWh.

The beneficiaries are the grid contractors and equipment suppliers. Balfour Beatty’s contract sits within National Grid’s GBP 8 billion Electricity Transmission Partnership, under which it became delivery partner for North East England in 2025. Gas plants south of the Scottish boundary are paid to run when wind is curtailed, which is a revenue stream for them at the system’s expense.

Competing views

Industry bodies in Germany accept the diagnosis but dispute the remedy. The Renewable Energy Federation of North Rhine-Westphalia (LEE NRW) argues that the government’s focus on redispatch costs ignores longer-term system costs such as fossil fuel imports. The BWE wind association warned on 30 July that, according to a trade report, approved wind projects are under financing pressure from the two bills.

At the Bundestag hearing, Bernhard Strohmayer of the bne association named the loss of the unconditional grid connection right in capacity-limited areas as the bill’s main problem. He argued that a grid operator would prefer to curtail plants with a redispatch reservation because it raises the operator’s economics, and that distribution grids would not be built out faster as a result. The same hearing record notes he considered the planned prioritisation and move away from first come, first served a correct step in principle.

Supporters of the draft, including the economy ministry led by Katherina Reiche (CDU), say the aim is to synchronise the expansion of grids and renewables better. Critics outside the industry point to the cost to consumers, and Britain has a parallel argument over who should fund transmission. Scottish Renewables says transmission charges remain the single biggest barrier to offshore wind deployment in Scotland, and its analysis suggests an additional GBP 2.9 billion in transmission costs across the existing generation fleet.

A likely reading

The data shows that congestion costs are growing faster than the infrastructure that would reduce them. A likely reading is that two policy models are emerging. Germany is using connection rules to price congestion into project economics. Britain is leaning on a large grid build programme and, in the industry’s view, on reforms to locational charging, while accepting high constraint payments in the interim.

Another reading, which is an interpretation and not a finding, is that wind developers will begin pricing curtailment risk explicitly into bids and financing, as the German reservation would require. Whether that lowers system costs or only moves them from bills to bid prices is unresolved. The ACER assessment of ERAA 2025 records that Germany’s projected wind capacity for 2030 is 24 GW lower than in the previous edition, which suggests system planners are already assuming slower build in some markets.

Risks and open questions

The German package is not law. The reservation’s thresholds changed between the draft and the cabinet version, and the Bundestag may change them again. Legal uncertainty is flagged in the hearing record, which says the provision on capacity-limited areas has avoidable ambiguities, and bne cites the EU internal market directive’s limits on restricting grid access.

Transparency is a second gap. WindEurope’s 2024 grid-access report said that across Europe there is very little transparency on annually curtailed renewable volumes and congestion costs. The figures in this article differ in scope for that reason.

The third is delivery. Grid projects that take years to permit and build, such as Birkhill Wood, only help if the generation they serve reaches FID on schedule. The reverse also holds: if offshore projects slip, the substation capacity sits idle. The cost totals for 2026 are partial-year figures and may move with wind conditions and replacement power prices.

What to watch

  • The Bundestag’s final vote on the EEG reform and grid package, expected by the end of 2026 according to Denkstrom, and whether the 5% trigger and the 18 to 20% cap survive.
  • NESO’s full-year 2026 constraint cost figure, and whether it tracks the GBP 3 billion to GBP 8 billion forecasts cited above.
  • Final investment decisions on Dogger Bank South East and South West, targeted for 2027, and the start of main construction at Birkhill Wood in the same year.
  • Whether developers’ bids in German onshore wind auctions begin to reflect curtailment risk once the new rules apply.
  • The next ENTSO-E and ACER data on congestion costs, which would allow a like-for-like European comparison.

Sources

Leave a Comment