EU eases carbon and methane rules as energy prices bite

The European Union is adjusting three of its main climate instruments at once, and the common cause is the cost of energy. The European Commission’s ETS review (17 July 2026), a provisional deal on the Market Stability Reserve (20 October) and a European Parliament vote to postpone methane import rules (22 October) all land within about 14 weeks of each other.

None of these files repeals anything. Together they show how Brussels is trading some climate stringency for political room as gas prices climb. This analysis sets out what has been decided, what is only proposed, and where the disagreement lies.

What has happened, and what is still only a proposal

The three decisions sit at different legal stages, which matters for anyone modelling their effect.

  • ETS review: a Commission proposal published on 17 July 2026 (COM(2026) 616), now under negotiation in the Council and Parliament. Nothing in it is law.
  • Market Stability Reserve (MSR) amendment: a provisional agreement between Council and Parliament reached on 20 October. According to the Council, it still needs formal confirmation by both institutions.
  • Methane regulation: the Commission proposed a one-year delay on 14 October. Parliament backed a three-year delay on 22 October, by 341 votes to 225 with 6 abstentions, according to S&P Global. Talks with the Council come next.

The backdrop is price. Prestige Business Solutions’ market report puts the December 2026 EU allowance (EUA) contract at €86.26 per tonne of CO2 on 23 October. Embapower reports that the front-month TTF gas contract briefly passed €97/MWh on 26 October, the first time since 2022, on colder weather forecasts.

The European Council’s 15 and 16 October conclusions cite soaring energy prices and the geopolitical situation. Leaders asked co-legislators to speed up the MSR file with a view to moderating excessive price volatility, and asked the Commission to update its impact assessment of ETS2, the planned carbon price on buildings and road fuels.

The ETS proposal in numbers

The Commission describes its proposal as keeping the carbon price signal while adding targeted simplifications. Law-firm and market summaries of the text show a lower pace of cap reduction, more free allocation for industry and a large investment fund.

Element Commission proposal, 17 July 2026 Reported size
Linear Reduction Factor, 2031 to 2035 Lowered from 4.3% a year 3.7%
Linear Reduction Factor, from 2036 Lowered from 4.3% a year 1.7%
Year the cap reaches zero Pushed back About 2039 to about 2048
MSR intake rate from 2028 Reduced 12%
Industrial Decarbonisation Bank New instrument €100 billion
Early “Investment Booster”, from 2028 Funded by allowances 400 million allowances, about €30 billion
Extra free allocation, 2026 to 2030 Revised benchmarks €6 billion (80 million allowances)
Permanent carbon removals Cap raised for auctioning, 2031 to 2040 250 million allowances

Sources for the table: Linklaters, Global ELR and carbonunits.com summaries of the Commission text, and green.earth. The Commission also proposes that member states spend at least 50% of national ETS revenues on decarbonising ETS sectors, according to Linklaters.

How the market read it

The data shows the carbon price rose after publication. The December contract closed at €79.11 on 17 July, according to Investing.com’s historical data, and green.earth reports EUAs reached €86 by 22 July as the confirmed details proved less bearish than worst-case expectations.

ClearBlue Markets modelling, cited by carbonunits.com, puts the EUA price at €138.5 in 2035, only €7 below an extension of current rules. On that view, the lower cap trajectory is largely offset by the redesigned reserve.

The case that the package costs investment

The Strategic Perspectives think tank, working with Veyt, reached a different conclusion on investment rather than price. Agence Europe reports the study, published on 7 October, finds that industrial investment between 2026 and 2040 would fall from €354 billion under current law to €302 billion if the proposal is adopted as it stands. Decarbonisation investment would fall from €329 billion to €239 billion, the €90 billion gap in the headline.

Industrial investment under current ETS law vs the Commission proposal, 2026 to 2040
Industrial investment under current ETS law vs the Commission proposal, 2026 to 2040

The same report, as summarised by Agence Europe, says carbon capture and storage, low-carbon steel and green hydrogen would be hit hardest. It says no new allowances would enter the market after 2048 instead of 2039, and that gross emissions could be more than 200 million tonnes of CO2 higher. Offsetting that would fall to buildings, road transport and agriculture, the sectors where carbon pricing is politically hardest.

The study is advocacy-adjacent: the Parliament Magazine op-ed that popularises it was written by Ursula Woodburn of CLG Europe. The Greens/EFA group has called the free-allocation increase a subsidy for fossil fuel industries. Bruegel argued earlier in the review process that weakening the system would undermine investment signals and penalise early movers.

The Commission and industry hold the opposite emphasis. Free allocation and the €100 billion bank are presented as support to keep industry competitive during the transition. Cepi, the pulp and paper federation, says the combined measures could still reduce industry’s investment capacity.

The reserve deal: a compromise between two positions

The MSR agreement shows how far the institutions were willing to go. The Commission’s April proposal would have stopped the automatic cancellation of allowances above 400 million units in the reserve. Agence Europe reports the Council and Parliament rejected an indefinite halt and instead raised the cancellation threshold to 700 million.

That figure sits between Parliament’s earlier 650 million and the Council’s 800 million, according to the same report. Eunews reports the higher threshold applies to invalidation from 1 January 2031.

MSR cancellation threshold: current rule and the positions in the October 2026 talks
MSR cancellation threshold: current rule and the positions in the October 2026 talks

The Council says the changes increase the reserve’s capacity to release allowances to shield industry from extreme price volatility, while keeping safeguards against surpluses. More than 3 billion allowances have been cancelled since the mechanism began in 2023, according to Eurometal.

A likely reading is that a larger reserve holds more allowances that could be released into a tight market, which caps price spikes without a formal price ceiling. Whether the 700 million level is loose enough to matter depends on how supply tightens after the mid-2030s, and that is a forecast, not a measurement.

Methane: the same pressure, a different instrument

The methane regulation, adopted in 2024, requires importers of oil, gas and coal under new contracts to show that supplier volumes meet the same monitoring, reporting and verification standards as EU production. S&P Global reports that these obligations start in 2027 under current law.

Item Commission, 14 October Parliament, 22 October
Length of delay 1 year (start moves to 1 January 2028) 3 years (to 2031)
Methane-intensity reporting deadline 5 August 2029 5 August 2031
Operator reporting on source-level measurements Delay in proposal 3 additional years
Status Legislative proposal Negotiating position; talks with Council next

Sources: Reuters via Investing.com, Eunews, S&P Global and discoveryalert.com for the reporting dates. Discoveryalert also notes the vote is not law: unless an amending law is published before 31 December, the original obligations apply from 1 January 2027. It adds that the delay excludes supply from sanctioned countries; treat that detail as secondary-source reporting.

The Commission framed its proposal around market turmoil linked to the Middle East war and the cost of a difficult winter, according to S&P Global. Reuters reported that the move followed pressure from several governments, including France and the United States. Agence Europe also reports that the Council failed to agree on the amendment at its first attempt.

Competing numbers on cost

Climate Action Network’s Flora Witkowski and Italian MEP Signorelli cite a loss of about €185 billion in benefits from a three-year delay. Signorelli, quoted by Eunews, sets that against €11 billion in savings and about 40,000 additional premature deaths. The sources do not say who produced the underlying model, so these are advocacy-side estimates that readers should treat as unverified.

Léa Pilsner of the Environmental Defense Fund told EU Perspectives the regulation did not cause the current price crisis and that postponing it will not solve it. She also disputes French President Emmanuel Macron’s argument that on-time application would raise prices during a fuel crisis, estimating the effect at a few cents per household per month.

On the other side, Parliament President Roberta Metsola called the vote a step to strengthen energy security that gives companies more time to prepare. Christian Ehler of the EPP group described the Commission’s one-year delay as far from sufficient, according to Euronews.

Who gains and who loses

Gains and losses depend on which proposal survives, but the direction is visible.

  • Energy-intensive industry: gains from more free allocation, the investment fund and a larger reserve to cap price spikes. It loses some certainty if the rules keep changing.
  • Early movers in low-carbon steel, hydrogen and CCS: face weaker relative returns if the Strategic Perspectives analysis is right. Their case rests on a predictable carbon price.
  • Gas importers and suppliers: gain time on methane compliance. Suppliers that invested early in measurement and reporting see their advantage deferred.
  • Households and power buyers: may gain if carbon-cost relief reaches electricity bills. The size of that effect is disputed in every source reviewed.
  • Member states with stricter climate targets: inherit more of the 2040 abatement burden, because the Strategic Perspectives report says buildings, transport and agriculture would have to cut deeper.

Risks and open questions

The EU’s 2040 target is a 90% net reduction in emissions from 1990 levels, as cited in the Parliament Magazine op-ed. The interaction between that target and a longer-lived cap has not been settled in the sources reviewed.

Resource Strategic questions remain on removals too. The RFF issue brief of 13 October notes that permanent carbon removal is costly, likely above the allowance price, so it is unclear how many removal units the system would actually buy.

There is also a sequencing risk. Italy and Czechia sent a joint paper on 30 September asking for temporary ETS relief and, in an Italian-Czech working document seen by Agence Europe, for ETS2 to be suspended. The European Council did not endorse suspension. It asked for an updated assessment of ETS2’s design and safeguards, which leaves the 2028 start open to debate.

Finally, the carbon price and gas are not moving in lockstep. Embapower noted that the EUA gained about 1% in the week to 23 October while gas rose 7.2%, a possible temporary weakening of the usual correlation. One week is too short to call a trend.

What to watch

  • Formal confirmation of the MSR deal by Parliament and Council, and how quickly the 700 million threshold takes effect.
  • Council and Parliament trilogue talks on the methane delay, and whether an amending law is published before 31 December. Without one, the 2027 import obligations apply.
  • Environment Council positions on the Linear Reduction Factor, free allocation and the Industrial Decarbonisation Bank within the ETS review.
  • The Commission’s updated ETS2 impact assessment requested by EU leaders.
  • Whether TTF holds near €97/MWh through winter, which sets the political pressure behind all three files.

Sources

Header photo of Berlaymont building: Matthias v.d. Elbe, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons.

Leave a Comment