US Senate tests a permitting bill built around transmission

The US Senate is scheduled to hold a cloture vote on 9 November 2026 on the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act (BAAJA, S.5653), a 417-page bill whose grid provisions would change how interstate power lines are planned, sited and paid for. According to MIT Technology Review, the vote comes days after midterm elections that have left the bill’s prospects unclear.

The vote is a procedural test. Foley Hoag notes that passage needs 60 votes and that any Senate bill must be reconciled with the House’s permitting legislation before the 119th Congress ends in January 2027.

What the bill would do to the grid

The text was released on 30 September 2026 by Senators Shelley Moore Capito, Mike Lee, Sheldon Whitehouse and Martin Heinrich, two Republicans and two Democrats. The transmission and grid provisions sit in Division B, Title I. The Columbia University Center on Global Energy Policy says they target three barriers: fragmented planning, state-by-state siting and uncertainty over who pays.

Provision Bill section What it would do
Federal backstop siting 2101 Lets FERC permit qualifying interstate lines without a prior DOE corridor designation
Regional and interregional planning 2103-2105 Requires each region to plan with neighbours and submit processes to FERC
Advanced transmission technologies 2109 Directs FERC to require them on new and modified lines
Distributed energy resources 2108 DOE programme for streamlined local permitting
Large loads Title I New loads of 20 MW or more pay full incremental grid costs
Offshore transmission 2252 Federal framework; Interior and DOE identify preferred routes

On siting, the Center for Climate and Energy Solutions (C2ES) summary says the bill would drop the National Interest Electric Transmission Corridor process as a precondition for federal backstop permitting. The Niskanen Center reads the new authority as covering lines above 230 kV, with developers able to apply to FERC and state regulators at the same time. The Congressional Research Service observes that this means some lines could be under state and federal review simultaneously.

On planning, the Bipartisan Policy Center says the bill codifies FERC Order 1920 and folds the planning framework into FERC’s backstop authority. Costs would follow benefits: customers would pay in proportion to tangible gains such as reliability and access to cheaper power, and those with no or trivial benefit could not be charged involuntarily.

Large loads are among the most contested elements. Under the Bipartisan Policy Center’s reading, new data centres of 20 MW or more would pay the full incremental cost of the infrastructure built to serve them. Data centres would pay both the published rate for the existing grid and the extra costs they cause, an “and pricing” model.

Interconnection: the queue the bill tries to shorten

The bill would require regions to plan generation and transmission together and to publish connection points with upfront, fixed costs. The Bipartisan Policy Center says this is modelled on a Southwest Power Pool process that FERC approved in March 2026.

The backlog it targets is large but shrinking. GCN, reporting Berkeley Lab’s Queued Up data, puts total US queue capacity at roughly 2,600 GW at the end of 2023, 2,290 GW at the end of 2024 and about 2,061 GW at the end of 2025.

Our calculation: 2,290 GW minus 2,061 GW is 229 GW, and 229 / 2,290 = 10.0%, so the active queue fell by about a tenth during 2025.

Active US interconnection queue capacity, end of year. Active queue capacity: End 2023 (approx.) 2600, End 2024 2290, End 2025 2061 (GW)
Active US interconnection queue capacity, end of year
Source: Berkeley Lab Queued Up data, as reported by GCN

A smaller queue does not mean faster connections. Berkeley Lab’s 2025 edition found that only 13% of capacity that requested interconnection between 2000 and 2019 had reached commercial operation by the end of 2024, while 77% had been withdrawn. In PJM’s first transition cycle, GCN reports, 84 projects totalling 14.3 GW received interconnection agreements.

The modelled numbers

Several groups have put figures on the bill. They use different scopes, baselines and time frames, so they are not directly comparable.

Analyst Scope Reported result
Rhodium Group US, to 2040 Household bills lower by $50 to $78 per year; 17 to 249 GW more clean capacity
Resources for the Future US, to 2050 Average annual system costs down 3.5% to 7%, saving $350 billion
C2ES with Greenline Insights Four grid regions, 2035 About $7 billion lower delivery costs; $1.1 billion lower residential bills
C2ES with Greenline Insights US, 2026 to 2040 About $125 billion lower grid costs; $19 billion lower residential bills

The Rhodium and Resources for the Future figures are as reported by the Bipartisan Policy Center; the capacity range is from Heatmap News. The C2ES regional result is net of $1.9 billion in new transmission investment, per Canary Media. The C2ES release carries the nationwide totals; Greenline’s Ashna Aggarwal said the modelling indicated almost 100 GW more wind, solar and storage and nearly 40 GW of added interregional transmission capacity.

The headline build-rate finding comes from the Rhodium Group. Heatmap reports that BAAJA could sharply raise high-voltage additions, from about 0.7 terawatt-miles a year over the past decade to 1.9 to 2.6 terawatt-miles a year through 2040. Rhodium’s model left out permit certainty, advanced transmission technologies and virtual power plants, and Heatmap notes the authors did not run a full network study, so the transmission effect may be undercounted.

US high-voltage transmission additions per year. Additions: Past decade average 0.7, BAAJA case, low (to 2040) 1.9, BAAJA case, high (to 2040) 2.6 (terawatt-miles per year)
US high-voltage transmission additions per year
Source: Rhodium Group modelling, as reported by Heatmap News

Who gains and who loses

The modelled gains accrue to ratepayers and to generators waiting on grid capacity. A likely reading is that merchant and interregional line developers gain most directly. The Institute for Progress says the bill gives developer-led lines a path to ratepayer-funded cost allocation and federal siting, which it says addresses all three of the main challenges merchant lines face.

Data centres bear a new cost. The Oil Change International analysis cites Rhodium estimates that the provisions could double electricity costs for data centres, a 10% rise in total annual operating costs. Oil Change, which opposes the bill, argues this could push developers to stay off the grid and build gas generation instead; that is its interpretation, not a finding of the Rhodium note.

Utilities with local projects face more scrutiny. The bill would let states ask FERC to investigate local transmission projects they believe harm ratepayers, according to the Bipartisan Policy Center.

The dispute is over the rest of the bill

Few of the critics attack the grid chapter. NRDC calls transmission and grid reform the bill’s principal strength and says it could cut the time to build a major new line to five to six years from about 10. It also calls other elements “deeply flawed”, saying they weaken the Clean Water Act, the Endangered Species Act, NEPA and the National Historic Preservation Act. NRDC says its initial results show modest power-sector benefits, and, as Latitude Media reports, it will take a position before the floor vote, as will the Sierra Club.

NRDC also argues that the “project certainty” language, which limits agencies’ ability to revoke permits, could benefit fossil fuel, mining and data centre projects more than clean energy. In its republished assessment on CleanTechnica, NRDC also says Trump administration actions could double power-sector emissions over the next decade and raise bills by $30 billion a year by 2035. That is NRDC’s own analysis of a separate question.

Tribal governments have objected to the changes to Section 106 of the National Historic Preservation Act. The All Pueblo Council of Governors unanimously adopted a resolution opposing the bill as introduced. Supporters see it differently. Americans for a Clean Energy Grid, a coalition of more than 75 groups, called the transmission provisions among the most significant grid reforms in decades, Daily Energy Insider reports. Representative Harder, a Build America Caucus chair, told Utility Dive that the cost-sharing elements are probably the most important part of the bill, and said the Section 106 dispute may be clarified.

Risks and open questions

The bill is a framework. As Inside Energy & Environment points out, it would set up a structure, not a final regulatory programme, so FERC rulemakings would decide how much capacity actually moves. The same source says negotiators expect further talks with the administration on lifting a moratorium on wind and solar permitting, which the current text does not address directly.

A further open question is timing. NRDC itself notes that transmission takes years to plan and build, so data-centre demand growth would arrive well before new lines do. Rhodium’s emissions result also depends on its data-centre demand assumption, and it tested faster-growth scenarios separately.

What to watch

  • The result of the 9 November cloture vote, and whether it reaches 60 votes.
  • Whether NRDC and the Sierra Club announce positions, and whether the Section 106 language is amended.
  • Any deal with the administration on the wind and solar permitting moratorium.
  • Reconciliation with the House bill before January 2027.
  • FERC’s early steps on interregional planning, large-load pricing and advanced transmission technologies, if the bill is enacted.

Sources

Header image: illustration, AI-generated.

Leave a Comment