Permitting bill and power-bill backlash collide before US midterms

A 417-page Senate bill, a record wave of utility rate requests and a Senate race in Ohio are pointing at the same underlying problem: the United States grid is straining to keep up with data-center demand, and voters are noticing on their electricity bills. The three threads come together around one date, November 9, 2026, when the Senate is expected to hold a cloture vote on the most comprehensive permitting overhaul put forward in years.

What happened

On September 30, 2026, four senators, Shelley Moore Capito (R-West Virginia), Mike Lee (R-Utah), Sheldon Whitehouse (D-Rhode Island) and Martin Heinrich (D-New Mexico), introduced the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, a 417-page bill text, after what reporting describes as years of negotiations and multiple stalled efforts. The bill, known as BAAJA, is a proposal, not law. It still needs 60 votes in the Senate and has no House companion yet.

The bill would rewrite how federal agencies review and litigate energy and infrastructure projects. It sets a one-year deadline for environmental assessments and a two-year deadline for full impact statements, and gives opponents 150 days to sue, not six years. It also narrows Section 401 of the Clean Water Act so states can no longer block pipelines on grounds that have nothing to do with water quality, lets projects keep moving forward while agencies fix paperwork a court has flagged, and protects issued permits from being yanked by a later administration. On data centers specifically, the bill targets delays in connecting new power sources to the grid and would require large data centre operators to contribute to grid upgrades.

Provision Current federal process Proposed under BAAJA
Environmental review timeline Can take up to a decade 1-year assessments, 2-year full impact statements
Window for opponents to sue Up to six years after approval 150 days
Clean Water Act Section 401 States can cite broad grounds to block projects Narrowed to water-quality grounds only
Paperwork flagged by courts Project typically halts Project can continue while agency fixes the flaw
Issued permits Can be revoked by a later administration Protected from revocation

The bill has endorsements from the US Chamber of Commerce and Citizens’ Climate Lobby, which sees it as a way to accelerate clean energy and grid expansion. A Senate cloture vote is expected the week of November 9; the bill will need 60 votes, and the House has yet to introduce its own version.

The numbers behind the backlash

The push for permitting reform is happening against a backdrop of rising electricity costs. According to the nonprofit PowerLines, which tracks state rate filings, electric and gas utilities requested nearly $31 billion in rate increases in 2025, more than double the $15 billion requested in 2024. Through the first three quarters of 2026, requests had already reached $23.1 billion, including a record $4.5 billion in the third quarter alone, more than double a year earlier.

US utility rate increase requests, 2024-2026
US utility rate increase requests, 2024-2026

Charles Hua, executive director of PowerLines, told Fortune that “this is no longer a boring, sleepy energy story,” adding he could not think of another election cycle before the 2026 midterms where electricity and utility bills were on the ballot. Separately, Fortune reports that US electricity prices have risen by roughly 40% on average over the last five years.

Data centers are not the only driver of that increase, grid operators point to aging infrastructure and extreme weather too, but their footprint is large and concentrated. On the PJM grid, which covers 13 Mid-Atlantic and Midwest states, the independent market monitor estimates data centers will add at least $23 billion to customer bills over the three years ending in May 2028. A Bloomberg analysis found wholesale electricity prices across 25,000 grid nodes have risen as much as 267% since 2020 in areas near major data-center clusters; fact-checks of that figure note it describes the rate utility companies pay producers, not the rates people pay to utility companies for their monthly residential electric bills, a distinction worth keeping in mind whenever the number is cited in political debate.

Who gains, who loses

Pipeline and transmission developers stand to gain the most direct benefit from BAAJA’s shorter review clocks and narrower litigation window. The bill’s supporters point to the Mountain Valley Pipeline, which carries natural gas 300 miles from West Virginia to southern Virginia and took nine years to permit, as the kind of delay the bill is meant to prevent. Faster federal review could also help wind, solar, storage and geothermal projects that have been stuck in the same queues, a point the libertarian Cato Institute makes in arguing that faster permitting can help wind, solar, geothermal, storage, and nuclear projects move forward, giving environmentalists plenty to gain from reform.

Large electricity users could face new costs. Several proposed bills, including the SHIELD Act from Representatives Mike Levin and Kathy Castor, aim to update federal utility policy to ensure that massive electricity users, rather than everyday ratepayers, bear the costs of the grid infrastructure they require. A separate Democratic bill from Representatives Sean Casten and Mike Levin, the Energy Bills Relief Act, would encourage the Interior Department and US Forest Service to permit wind, solar and geothermal projects on public lands, and would make sure facilities like data centers pay their own electricity costs; it had at least 118 Democratic co-sponsors as of its introduction but faces long odds in a Republican Congress.

Not every stakeholder is aligned even within the coalition backing BAAJA. Regulators in five states with no renewable mandates have pushed back on how transmission costs tied to grid expansion get shared. Regulators from Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Dakota and Montana filed a FERC complaint arguing the benefits were inflated and that the setup lets states with aggressive “green” goals shift their higher transmission bills onto neighbors who made different choices, concerns MISO’s own independent market monitor has raised as well. That dispute signals that even a bipartisan deal in Washington will not settle every fight over who pays for new power lines.

Competing views on the bill

Conservative commentators broadly welcome BAAJA but want it tightened further. E.J. Antoni, chief economist at the Heritage Foundation, called it “the most serious permitting reform in a generation” while arguing Congress should take a “mend-it-don’t-end-it” approach rather than attaching what he calls gimmicks that risk funding subsidies he says voters already rejected.

Progressive Democrats have taken a different tack, focusing less on permitting speed and more on cost allocation. Representative Sean Casten, co-sponsor of the Energy Bills Relief Act, told reporters the bill is meant as “a good messaging bill,” but added, “more importantly, it’s good policy”, framing the debate around who pays rather than how fast projects move.

Centrist and industry analysts see BAAJA as a rare point of convergence. A legal analysis of the bill notes that it reflects a set of political and economic drivers, including rising electricity demand, transmission constraints, energy affordability concerns, domestic manufacturing priorities and the rapid growth of data centers and artificial intelligence infrastructure, which have helped produce a coalition of support that extends beyond traditional energy advocates. That coalition failed to materialize behind the narrower 2024 bill from then-Senator Joe Manchin and Senator John Barrasso, which made similar moves but never made it out of the Natural Resources Committee.

The Ohio test case

Nowhere does the politics of power bills and data centers show up more clearly than in Ohio’s Senate race. Ohio has 154 operational data center facilities and 84 more in the works, more than all but three other states, after the state agreed to sales tax exemptions to attract the investment in the 2010s. Republican Senator Jon Husted, appointed to his seat after JD Vance became vice president, is being challenged by Democrat Sherrod Brown, who lost his previous Senate seat in 2024 and is attempting a comeback.

Ohio US Senate race: recent poll margins
Ohio US Senate race: recent poll margins

Brown has made data centers central to his campaign, running ads that call Husted “the face of data centers” and claiming Husted “gave away two and a half billion dollars to these out-of-state corporations and billionaires” in state tax breaks, including to Meta. Recent surveys show a close race: an NYT/Siena poll gave Brown a 49% to 46% lead, and a Suffolk University poll put Brown ahead 47% to 44%, both within or near their margins of error. That marks a shift from an earlier Emerson College poll that had Husted leading Brown 50% to 44% before Brown’s favorability advantage became apparent.

National Republicans are alarmed. A National Republican Senatorial Committee memo obtained by ABC News reportedly called data centers “the anchor hanging around Husted’s neck” and warned that if he loses and data centers get the blame, politicians across the country will take notice and will not go near the next one. The dynamic is not confined to Ohio: data center backlash is reshaping midterm races, with 39 local ballot measures in eight states, and a Gallup poll found 71% of Americans oppose data centers in their communities, according to the March 2026 survey cited by Forbes.

Risks and open questions

Three uncertainties stand out. First, BAAJA’s fate is not settled: it needs 60 votes in a Senate where, one analysis notes, bipartisan backing makes the bill less exposed to the midterm results, but the 2024 bill stalled in a similar lame-duck window. Second, even if it passes the Senate, the House has not introduced companion legislation, leaving the timeline for enactment unclear.

Third, it is not obvious that permitting reform alone will lower electricity bills quickly, or that making data centers “pay their own way” is simple to define or enforce across 50 different state utility commissions, each with its own rate-setting process. The data show rate requests accelerating regardless of which policy fix is debated in Washington; a likely reading is that near-term bills will keep rising while Congress and state regulators sort out cost allocation, even if BAAJA becomes law. The FERC complaint from Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Dakota and Montana regulators also signals that transmission cost-sharing disputes could outlast any one piece of federal legislation.

What to watch

  • The Senate cloture vote expected the week of November 9, 2026, and whether BAAJA clears the 60-vote threshold.
  • Whether the House introduces a companion permitting bill, and how it treats data-center cost allocation differently from the Senate text.
  • Fourth-quarter 2026 state rate filings, to see whether PowerLines’ $23.1 billion year-to-date tally approaches or exceeds the 2025 record of $31 billion.
  • The outcome of the FERC complaint from regulators in Arkansas, Louisiana, Mississippi, North Dakota and Montana over MISO transmission cost allocation.
  • Results in Ohio’s Senate race and the 39 local data-center ballot measures across eight states, as an early signal of how affordability politics shapes state-level energy and siting policy after the midterms.

Sources