NESO forecasts UK grid constraint costs of £3.9bn in 2027

The National Energy System Operator (NESO) expects the cost of managing congestion on Great Britain’s transmission network to reach £3.9 billion in calendar 2027, up from around £2 billion in 2025/26, according to Utility Week. The forecast, published on Thursday 12 November 2026, covers thermal constraints only, the payments NESO makes when lines cannot carry all the power the market has scheduled.

It is the most consequential grid-market story of the week because it puts a price on a mismatch that many systems share: generation connects faster than the wires that carry it. The detail also shows an awkward feature of the fix. Building the new network requires taking the old network out of service, and that raises the bill first.

What the forecast says

Thermal constraints arise when power would naturally flow from one region to another in volumes that exceed the capacity of the connecting circuits, as NESO’s data portal describes them. NESO then pays generators in the constrained area to cut output and pays others elsewhere to run. According to Briefs Finance, constraint payments reached a record £2.7 billion through October, and NESO’s scenarios suggest the bill could reach £7.7 billion per year by 2030 at the upper end.

Our calculation: (£3.9bn − £2.0bn) ÷ £2.0bn = 0.95, a 95% rise. The two figures use different periods (calendar 2027 against financial year 2025/26), so treat the ratio as indicative.

GB thermal constraint costs: outturn, forecast and 2030 scenario. Thermal constraint costs: 2024/25 outturn 1.34, 2025/26 outturn 2, 2027 forecast 3.9, 2030 upper scenario 7.7 (GBP billion)
GB thermal constraint costs: outturn, forecast and 2030 scenario
Source: DESNZ Reformed National Pricing delivery plan (2024/25); Utility Week on NESO (2025/26, 2027); Briefs Finance on NESO (2030 upper scenario). Periods and price bases differ.

The chart shows the outturn and forecast path: £1.34 billion in 2024/25, about £2.0 billion in 2025/26, £3.9 billion forecast for 2027 and up to £7.7 billion in the upper 2030 scenario. The 2024/25 figure comes from the government’s Reformed National Pricing delivery plan, which says NESO spent £1.34 billion on direct actions to manage thermal constraints that year. Price bases differ between bars, and the 2030 figure is a scenario, not a forecast of what will be paid.

Why the bill rises before it falls

The data shows three drivers. The first is outages. NESO’s own BSUoS forecast for November 2026 puts that month’s balancing costs at £439 million, 12% (£48m) higher than the 21 September forecast of £391m. NESO attributes a 10% (£30m) rise in the constraints element partly to a challenging outage plan that transmission owners need in order to maintain and upgrade their networks. In the 2027 forecast, NESO estimates costs would be 16% lower without network outages, according to CryptoSlate’s reading of the report.

The second is gas. Because most of the money goes on replacement power, the price of fuel matters as much as the volume of wind turned down. CryptoSlate reports NESO figures showing about 75% of 2025/26 thermal constraint costs covered replacement supply, mainly gas, and that a little under £500 million was paid to wind farms to curtail output that year. That is roughly a quarter of the £2.0 billion, which fits the 75% share.

The third is geography. NESO’s network requirements pages expect Scotland to stay a net exporter, with 38 GW of generation against about 6 GW of demand by 2030 under its Holistic Transition scenario. CryptoSlate cites NESO as saying 28% of wind above the B6 boundary was curtailed in 2025/26, against 13% across Great Britain.

Pressure is visible in recent operations. Energy Connects reported in October that, based on LCP Delta data, the UK paid a record of just over half a billion pounds in September to balance its power system, and that transmission infrastructure in southeast England expected back in service remained unavailable.

The estimates side by side

Source Period What it measures Figure (£bn)
Government delivery plan 2024/25 Outturn, direct thermal constraint actions 1.34
NESO via Utility Week 2025/26 Outturn, thermal constraints about 2.0
NESO via Utility Week Calendar 2027 Forecast, thermal constraints 3.9
NESO via Briefs Finance 2030 Upper-end scenario 7.7
Government delivery plan 2030/31 Projected peak without further measures about 7
National Audit Office 2030 Range if upgrades slip (2024 prices) 6.6 to 7.8
LCP Delta 2030 Own modelling, before and after reform measures 6.1 and 2.3

The National Audit Office (11 September 2026) says constraint costs could reach £6.6 billion to £7.8 billion in 2030 if grid upgrades are late, and many of the 88 grid upgrades are at risk of not being completed when needed. Its summary adds that with no upgrade at all, costs could reach £12.7 billion a year.

Estimates of GB constraint costs in 2030. 2030 constraint cost estimate: NESO Nov 2026 (upper) 7.7, NESO earlier (via LCP) 7.4, Government plan 7, LCP Delta, no reform 6.1, LCP Delta, with reform 2.3 (GBP billion)
Estimates of GB constraint costs in 2030
Source: Briefs Finance on NESO; LCP Delta press release; DESNZ Reformed National Pricing delivery plan. Vintages and price bases differ.

The second chart compares 2030 estimates from the government, NESO and LCP Delta. They come from different dates and price bases, so the spread of £6.1 billion to £7.7 billion for the no-reform case reflects method as much as disagreement. The £2.3 billion bar is LCP Delta’s estimate with reform measures applied.

Who pays, who gains, who loses

Consumers pay. WindAction reports NESO’s statement that the costs it incurs to manage the system are recovered through household and business energy bills. Constraint costs are the biggest single element of those balancing costs, and NESO says thermal constraints account for the largest share of the forecast growth.

Generators in the constrained north are paid to switch off, but those payments are the smaller part. The larger flow goes to dispatchable plant in the south, mostly gas, which runs to replace what Scotland cannot export. A likely reading is that the system is paying twice for the same electricity, once to wind owners to stop and once to gas owners to start. NESO’s caveat is that cutting a constraint cost does not automatically cut total consumer cost, because an action can add costs elsewhere.

Transmission owners and equipment suppliers stand to gain from the build-out, since every reinforcement that removes a bottleneck also requires outages. Wind developers behind the B6 boundary bear the curtailment risk. Their revenue depends on how much of the output NESO accepts, and the 28% curtailment rate cited above shows how large that exposure is for Scottish projects.

Competing views on the way out

NESO. Rebecca Beresford, NESO’s director of market, said in an interview carried by Briefs Finance: “Constraint costs are extremely high, and they have increased since last year”. She said the system is becoming more complicated to operate. NESO’s scenarios show costs dropping sharply after 2030 as major reinforcements move more power from north to south, then surging again by 2035 if generation is built faster than the network can handle.

Government. The delivery plan says internal estimates suggest up to £1 billion in savings in 2030 from operational measures, and that accelerating three transmission projects from 2031 to 2030 could cut 2030 costs by around £4 billion. The National Audit Office notes that NESO recommended those three projects be accelerated, and says one further project has been delayed beyond 2030.

Consultants and generators. LCP Delta, in a press release on the delivery plan, says four reform measures could reduce 2030 constraint cost by up to £3.8bn, a decrease of 60%. EDF argued earlier in 2026 that early evidence indicated constraint costs were not accelerating as quickly as forecast, and asked which pathway Britain is on. NESO’s November numbers, with projections higher than a year ago, point the other way for now.

Flexible demand: real, but small against the problem

NESO’s main new tool is Demand for Constraints, a long-term contract for flexible consumers in constrained areas that raise their consumption when lines are congested. A NESO webinar sets out up to 150 MW during 2028 and up to 300 MW thereafter, targeted at the Scottish B2, B4, B5 and B6 boundaries, with delivery possible from 2028.

NESO’s Q3 2026 flexibility review adds that, from 7 October 2026, NESO will begin procuring selected Scottish constraint management actions through its Demand Flexibility Service, folding the local constraints market into one route to market.

The scale comparison is stark. A 300 MW cap sits against roughly 6 GW of Scottish demand and 38 GW of Scottish generation in one NESO scenario for 2030. A likely reading is that flexible demand trims the cost at the margin and cannot substitute for transmission. CryptoSlate makes a related point: adding northern demand does not deliver more power south, so replacement supply is still needed in the south while the boundary binds.

The same mismatch in the US

The US shows the pattern from the other direction: demand and generation requests are racing ahead of network capacity. PJM Interconnection said on 29 April 2026 that 811 new generation projects, capable of generating 220 gigawatts, applied to connect through the first cycle of its reformed process. Utility Dive reports the cycle includes 106 GW of gas-fired generation, 67 GW of storage, 18 GW of nuclear, 15 GW of solar, 9 GW of solar-storage hybrid and 5 GW of wind. PJM expects reviews to take one to two years.

History is the caution. Renewable Energy World reports that since 2020 PJM has completed interconnection agreements for 103 GW, but only 23 GW have gone into service. On the demand side, insurance broker Howden says US data centre demand has grown 19% a year since 2000 against 2% a year for grid capacity, and estimates power constraints add 24 to 72 months to data centre build times. Both are company or trade-body analyses rather than regulator data.

Risks and open questions

The forecast is sensitive to gas prices, network availability and operational events, so a mild winter or an outage that finishes early would move it. The outage-driven part is a deliberate trade, since the upgrades are what lower the 2030s bill, but the NAO’s warning on delayed projects means the payoff date is uncertain.

Policy design is the second variable. The government’s Reformed National Pricing programme and NESO’s constraint-management services both aim to reduce volumes. Their combined effect is a modelled range from LCP Delta and the government, not a measured result. Third, the post-2030 shape depends on whether new generation is sited near network capacity; NESO’s own scenarios show costs returning by 2035 if it is not.

What to watch

  • Monthly NESO balancing cost and BSUoS forecasts, to see whether the 2027 path of £3.9 billion is revised.
  • Delivery dates for the 88 grid upgrades the NAO flags as at risk, and for the three accelerated projects.
  • The Demand for Constraints consultation (planned March 2027, according to NESO’s webinar timeline) and the 150 MW first-year volume.
  • The first results of Scottish constraint actions procured through the Demand Flexibility Service from 7 October 2026.
  • PJM’s Cycle 1 study results, to test whether 220 GW of applications turn into agreements faster than the earlier queue.

Sources

Header image: illustration, AI-generated.

Leave a Comment